Jimmy Joy Review

Jimmy Joy is a nutritional meal replacement shake, and the company is from the Netherlands. CEO Sam Rohn made a statement midway through February, 2017 on the website that the company was going to change their name from Joylent to Jimmy Joy. The company first started in 2014, and they offer a variety of products, like the Plenny shake, Plenny shake vegan, Plenny shake wake up, and Plenny shake sport. The company touts that these healthy shakes will give you all the nutrition you need without any effort at all. There are three different price point options with their shakes: 15 meals for 30 Euros, 30 meals for 55 Euros, or 90 meals for 150 Euros. This does not include shipping, and there are five different flavors to choose from (banana, strawberry, chocolate, vanilla, and mango). 

Company Contact Information 

Archangelkade 17D, 1013 BE Amsterdam, Netherlands 

Jimmy Joy Claims 

There are minimal claims made on the website overall. They do talk about what the product is made with and why it is important for consumption.  

“Made from real food. Plenny shake contains a carefully chosen mix of ingredients including proteins, carbs, fats, vitamins, and minerals that your body needs to stay healthy. They are sourced from oats, soy, flaxseed, and milk, while real flash dried fruit powder makes for that awesome taste. Finally, we added a custom blend of 27 essential vitamins and minerals to make it all complete. You’re welcome, body.” [1 

The company also says that all of the vitamins and minerals present in the shake hit the European Union’s daily intake of nutrients numbers, which means the shakes won’t deprive you of any nutrition. There are very minimal claims being made about the actual effectiveness of the product itself, but they are rather pointed towards food being a hassle. CEO Rohn says,  

“Food. Love it or hate it, you can’t live without it. Extensive research (no, not just a quick search on Google) has shown that meals eat up approximately 231,575.34 hours of your life. Just think of all that time that you could have spent solving world peace, becoming a dog whisperer, or finishing medical school.” [2] 

They also claim,  

“Plenny Shake is developed and manufactured for regular adult consumers. Please consult with your doctor if you have any doubts about whether you should drink it or not. Plenny Shake is not intended for children under the age of 18 or women in pregnancy. Plenny Shake contains Whey Protein concentrate, which contains small amounts of cow milk, lactose and soy lecithin. Plenny Shake also contains soy flour, full of soy protein, and oat flour, which may contain gluten and traces of nuts and peanuts.” [3] 

According to policy, the sport version of the Plenny shake is not allowed in the United States, so this is their only product that cannot be shipped here. This is because of the ingredient glucosamine sulfate, which is not approved by the FDA but is found in the ingredient list. What is glucosamine sulfate?

According to RX list,  

“Glucosamine sulfate is a naturally occurring chemical found in the human body. It is in the fluid that is around joints. Glucosamine is also found in other places in nature. For example, the glucosamine sulfate that is put into dietary supplements is often harvested from the shells of shellfish.” [4] 

Jimmy Joy Ingredients 

I will only be highlighting the shake ingredients, not the bar. 

Plenny Shake 

“Mix 175g Jimmy Joy with 500ml water. One bag Jimmy Joy contains 3 servings. Ingredients: oatmeal (gluten), Jimmy Joy Vitamix (maltodextrin, sodium citrate, sel, choline bitartrate, calcium carbonate, magnesium oxide, vitamin C, vitamin E, chromium chloride, niacin, vitamin A, sodium uoride, pantothenic acid, potassium iodide, vitamin D3, vitamin B12, biotin, folic acid, vitamin K1, ribo avin, copper sulphate monohydrate, vitamin B6), soy flour, whey protein concentrate mix (whey protein concentrate (milk, soy), banana flavour, thickener: guar gum, sweetener: sucralose), ground flaxseed, banana powder.” [5] 

Plenny Shake Vegan

Ingredients: oatmeal (gluten), Jimmy Joy Vitamix (maltodextrin, sodium citrate, sel, choline bitartrate, calcium carbonate, magnesium oxide, vitamin C, vitamin E, chromium chloride, niacin, vitamin A, sodium uoride, pantothenic acid, potassium iodide, vitamin D3, vitamin B12, biotin, folic acid, vitamin K1, ribo avin, copper sulphate monohydrate, vitamin B6), soy our, vegan protein mix (soy protein, hemp protein, rice protein, banana flavour, sweetener: sucralose), ground axseed, banana powder.” [6] 

Plenny Shake Wake Up

“Ingredients: oatmeal (gluten), Jimmy joy wake up Vitamix (maltodextrin, sodium citrate, sel, choline bitartrate, calcium carbonate, magnesium oxide, vitamin C, vitamin E, chromium chloride, niacin, vitamin A, sodium uoride, pantothenic acid, potassium iodide, vitamin D3, vitamin B12, biotin, folic acid, vitamin K1, ribo avin, copper sulphate monohydrate, vitamin B6), soy flour, whey protein concentrate mix (whey protein concentrate (milk, soy), cappuccino flavour, thickener: guar gum, ca eine sweetener: sucralose), ground axseed, beta alanine.” [7] 

Plenny Shake Sport

“Ingredients: oatmeal (gluten), Plenny shake Sport vitamin mix (maltodextrin, sodium citrate, sel, choline bitartrate, calcium carbonate, magnesium oxide, vitamin C, vitamin E, chromium chloride, niacin, vitamin A, sodium uoride, pantothenic acid, potassium iodide, vitamin D3, vitamin B12, biotin, folic acid, vitamin K1, ribo avin, copper sulphate monohydrate, vitamin B6), soy flour, whey protein concentrate mix (whey protein concentrate (milk, soy), banana a- vour, thickener: guar gum, sweetener: sucralose), corn starch, ground axseed, banana powder, creatine monohydrate, beta-alanine, glucosamine sulfate, acetyl L-carnitine.” [8] 

The Science (or Lack Thereof) Behind Jimmy Joy 

There are no claims made that need to be backed by a study from the website. The whole concept of drinking your calories throughout the day instead of eating them is rather new to the scene. Nowhere on the main site do they provide any background information as to how they came up with their formula in the first place. The idea that you should do away with food in the first place is rather crazy, and I think it won’t ever catch on like they are hoping it will. There is, however, a large amount of protein per serving which is around 45 g per meal. This will keep you filled for longer periods of time. 

Word On The Street About Jimmy Joy 

When looking into honest reviews by people outside of the main website, they were very few and far between. Many people on Reddit found that the product did work well, but some people really were sick of the flavors and the aftertaste it would give off. Others complained that the consistency was very hard to swallow if you did not blend it up first, as the shaker cup just wouldn’t do the job. Overall, however, there was a positive vibe and many people were agreeing with each other that Jimmy Joy’s has a pretty good shake in the end. One of the big problem is that production happens overseas, so the shipping is going to be expensive and take long because it is not sold anywhere in the United States.  

Ilari (2017, 3 star),  

“Filling, satisfying and the taste is okay. Will be a good lazy day meal replacement and an emergency meal for hikes. The only problem is the sweetener, the presence of artificial sweeteners with the tagline “made with real food” is misleading IMO. I wish there was a version of the Jimmy Joys without the horrible aftertaste of sucralose.” [9] 

Brenda (2017, 5 star),  

“Love your product, (huge fan of the chocolate!) but I am not a huge fan of the packaging of the powder. Trying to scoop the powder out of the zipper is near impossible without getting on my hand and then all over my counter. But all in all the product is great. Very filling and has a great taste that is not ruined by a bunch of sweetness.” [9] 

There were very few reviews posted anywhere about this company and their products, but the ones I was able to find highlighted the overall customer experience. They are promoting a greener and cleaner environment, as well as a more simple and effortless way to get nutrients throughout your busy workday. Weight loss is not at the pinnacle of their marketing tactic, but it was mentioned as a result if you just drink their shakes and nothing more. This will not work for everyone, but it is an option if you are looking for an alternative way to get fed.  

The Bottom Line: Is Jimmy Joy Worth A Try? 

Yes. This company seems innovative, quirky, and new to the scene, which means they are changing constantly. Even though shipping time seems to take a while, it might not be a terrible option to try out if you are in the market for a liquid diet. Some quivered at the consistency of the shakes, and didn’t dare leave them in the refrigerator overnight due to the thickening effect that takes place. Others thought they tasted good enough to keep on drinking them day after day to save time, money, and energy, all while getting the nutrients they need throughout the day. This shake does not come with any side effects, and it should be pretty easy on the stomach overall. There is nothing dangerous about them, but if you get the sport version be mindful that it contains glucosamine sulfate as well as creatine, if you are not wanting to ingest those two ingredients.

Top 5 Diets in 2018*

Program Price
Food Recipes
Health Coaches
Phone support
Email Support
Support Group
6 Month MBG
#1 PS1000 Plan
$$
#2 Trim Down Club
$
#3 Ketogenic Diet
$$$
#4 Weight Watchers
$$$$
#5 Medifast
$$$$

*Individual results will vary.

Information on this website is not to replace the advise of the doctor, but rather for general education purposes. It is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease and should not be considered as medical advice. Aways consult your doctor before starting any diet or taking any dietary supplements.

Articles, reviews and investigations are our own opinion, and written based on the information publicly available or simply contacting the companies. We try our best to stay up to date with constantly changing information. If you find any information inaccurate, please email us, we’ll verify for accuracy and update it.

Disclosure: some of the links on this website are affiliate links. This means that if you purchase an item following one of the links, we will receive a commission. Regardless of that, we only recommend the products or services, that we strongly believe will benefit our readers. Read full disclosure here.”