Update: 05/24/2019 - Advertising Disclosure

South Beach Diet Review

South Beach Diet Review
Reading Time: 3 minutesThe South Beach Diet was created back in 2003, its main purpose to eliminate all bad carbohydrates from a user’s diet. Cardiologist Dr. Arthur Agatston first came up with the program, published in book form. There’s no calorie counting, and the foods are higher in proteins and fats. It’s marketed to people wanting to lose weight, to become healthier, and to adopt these eating habits for life. [1]

How Does The South Beach Diet Work?

There are three phases to the South Beach diet, plus their own food line for shipment and purchase that takes the thinking out of eating. According to the website:

Phase 1: Your 7-Day Body Reboot

See results in your first week. Reset your body for fast weight loss. Burn fat and transform your metabolism with a high-protein low-carb plan. Enjoy delicious, fully prepared South Beach Diet® entrees, snack bars and shakes. Specially selected foods and meal plan make Phase 1 easy. Reduce your cravings for sugar and refined starches.

Phase 2: Steady Weight Loss

Keep losing weight to hit your goal. Add in good carbs from whole grains, fruits and more vegetables. Save time with delicious, fully prepared South Beach Diet® meals each week. Enjoy added flexibility with one DIY breakfast, lunch and dinner each week. Transform your body with simple fitness tips.

Phase 3: You’ve Got This!

Learn the way to maintain a healthy weight without hunger or deprivation. Enjoy all foods in moderation. Easily follow the basic South Beach Diet® principles. Look your best. Enjoy optimal health. Eat happy and healthy for life! [2]

And some medical and nutritional professionals aren’t convinced with Dr. Agatston’s science: 

as of the early 2000’s, there is no scientific proof that eating low-GI foods will have any more weight loss effect than eating a normal, calorie-reduced diet that includes carbohydrates; that Dr. Agatston also fails to take into account the interaction of different foods when eaten together, which can dramatically alter glucose metabolism; and that this failure means that utilizing the Glycemic Index as a gauge for what foods to eat is not only confusing but also slightly misleading. (emphasis added)

The book itself runs around $10.00. But if you choose home delivery, meals will come to your door for 4 weeks at a cost of $339.99—that’s for one person. It doesn’t include food or meal prep time for other family members.

One customer who purchased just the book said:

This diet is full of common sense and I have lost weight by following the guidelines. It is easy to follow with lots of veggies, sensible proteins and cutting out processed foods, white flour and sugar. There are some errors in the book though. In the first two week phase, you are supposed to avoid carrots (higher sugar content) yet in the first phase recipe section, the recipe includes carrots.

back to menu ↑

Is The South Beach Diet Safe?

The diet itself seems logically safe, with no dangerous supplements promising immediate and unrealistic weight loss. The meals and snacks they offer aren’t full of unpronounceable ingredients.  South Beach’s main focus is to provide the dieter with a well-balanced nutritional platform and educate about good versus bad carbohydrates.

back to menu ↑

Pros And Cons Of The South Beach Diet

The bones of this diet are easy to follow and understand; there is no measuring or counting calories. Eliminating refined carbohydrates and sugar will help you feel healthier overall, with or without weight loss. The South Beach Diet promotes eating six small meals per day, which levels your blood sugar rather than a cycle of skyrocket/crash. [4]

But it has some problems. This diet is very low in calcium, so you will definitely need a supplement in order to hit your daily requirement. In Phase 2 you are allowed two cups of dairy per day, but this is still not enough.

If you purchase the diet program from South Beach’s main website, you are roped into purchasing all of your meals and snacks at a cost of hundreds of dollars per month. And not all the reviews on the taste of those expensive meals are positive.

Even if you just purchase the diet book and forego the pre-made meals, you still have to make a lifestyle change. Getting your body into a state of ketosis—the whole point of all low-carb diets, where you burn fat because the carbs are all but gone—can have temporary side effects like dizziness, nausea, lethargy, and brain-fog.

back to menu ↑

The Bottom Line

The South Beach Diet hasn’t really set itself apart from other low-carb programs, though there’s nothing inherently wrong with it. It’s marketed to the masses with plenty of celebrity endorsements but seems to have helped enough people to justify the no-doubt pricey promotion. It’s strict but not dangerous, though it does lack sufficient calcium. The price tag is high, but pre-made meals may be worth the investment for some. I didn’t see much in the way of raving or panning the taste of the shipped meals; mostly it came across as edible but not exactly something to get excited over. And of course, once you hit your goal weight you’ll still need to follow the South Beach guidelines. All in all, there are cheaper ways to go low-carb.

Among many weight loss options out there we really like Trim Down Club (Read Review | Visit Website) and PhenQ (Read Review | Visit Website).

You can certainly learn from publications like South Beach Diet. However, Trim Down Club offers a lot of value and an excellent program with proven results. You’ll have a large community of members and great support. Something that South Beach Diet will lack.

PhenQ is a supplement that offers 5 practical solutions to weight loss: burns fat, suppresses appetite, blocks fat production, boosts energy, and even improves mood.

Why we prefer Trim Down Club over South Beach Diet?

  • Over 1 million members
  • Nutrition and long-term health in mind at every step
  • Meal planners and other unique tools
  • No promotion of crash dieting
  • Great support
  • Inexpensive
  • Instant access

Visit Trim Down Club

Why we prefer PhenQ over South Beach Diet?

  • 5 weight loss pills in one
  • 1900,000 satisfied customers
  • Unique weight loss supplement
  • Burns stored fat
  • Suppresses appetite
  • Blocks fat production
  • Boosts energy
  • Improves mood
  • Free shipping

Visit PhenQ

3.7 Total Score
South Beach Diet Scorecard

5.7Expert Score
Quality
6
Value
5.5
Satisfaction
5.5
1.7User's score
Quality
1.7
Value
1.7
Satisfaction
1.8
Add your review Read user reviews

Top Rated
Weight Loss Solutions in 2019

#1 Rated
Diet Program
#1 Rated
Diet Pill
#1 Rated
Meal Delivery
#1 Rated
Shake
Trim Down Club PhenQDiet-To-Go 18 Shake
How does it work?
How does it work?Proprietary meal planner, healthy recipes and avoiding certain foods help shed unwanted pounds.Fat burner, fat blocker, appetite suppressant, and energy booster in one pill. Use it alone or in combination with an eating plan.Perfectly portioned and convenient meals take the guesswork out of the successful weight loss.Replaces meals with low calorie, filling, and tasty protein shake. Over time reduced calories help shed unwanted pounds.
 Who is it for?
Who is it for?People who want to cook their own meals and learn healthy eating habits.People who want help to curb their appetite, get more energy, and burn more fat.Busy people who prefer the convenience of delivered nutritionally balanced meals, instead of spending time in the kitchen.Busy people who prefer quick and easy meal replacement on-the-go to help curb their hunger and save on calories.
 Includes supplements
Includes supplements
 Metabolism increase
Metabolism increase
 Energy increase
Energy increase
 Reduced cravings
Reduced cravings
 Reduced fatigue
Reduced fatigue
 Feeling fuller for longer
Feeling fuller for longer
 Protected muscles
Protected muscles
 Food Recipes
Food Recipes
 Health Coaches
Health Coaches
 Phone support
Phone support
 Email Support
Email Support
 

*Please keep in mind that with any diet or weight loss program, individual results will vary.

This content is strictly the opinion of ConsumersCompare.org and is for informational and educational purposes only. It is not intended to provide medical advice or to take the place of medical advice or treatment from a personal physician. All readers/viewers of this content are advised to consult their doctors or qualified health professionals regarding specific health questions. Neither ConsumersCompare.org nor the publisher of this content takes responsibility for possible health consequences of any person or persons reading or following the information in this educational content. All viewers of this content, especially those taking prescription or over-the-counter medications, should consult their physicians before beginning any nutrition, supplement or lifestyle program.

Read full Medical Disclaimer here.

CUSTOMER REVIEWS

25 Comments
Show all Most Helpful Highest Rating Lowest Rating Add your review
  1. 1
    Quality
    20
    Value
    20
    Satisfaction
    20

    I wish I had seen this website BEFORE I ordered. The food is terrible. When I told them I did not like the food, they wanted to know if I tried adding spices, etc. The food it WAY over spiced as it is. Phase I is mostly protein shakes. Seriously, who can do that 3 meals a day? I’m trying to eat as much as I can so I don’t waste money but it is a struggle. I had no idea they set me up for auto delivery. I just called to try and cancel and after asking 900 questions and me finally telling them “I JUST WANT TO CANCEL, NO MORE QUESTIONS”, I was told there would be a $120 cancellation fee. Really? I filed a complaint with the PA Attorney General and will dispute the charge on my credit card if they try charging me for a second shipment.

    Helpful(0) Unhelpful(0)You have already voted this
  2. 1
    Quality
    20
    Value
    20
    Satisfaction
    20

    BUYER BEWARE!!!! Terms and conditions obligate you to automatic shipments. If you cancel they charge back all the discounts they gave you with the first order. They bury this at checkout “terms and conditions” – biggest scam ever! Don’t fall for it!

    Helpful(0) Unhelpful(0)You have already voted this
  3. 1
    Quality
    20
    Value
    20
    Satisfaction
    20

    Yes … I was Nutrisystem before South Beach and it’s 100xs better…. including the counseling department and customer support. I also read that Nutrisystem bought out South Beach which I think was a big mistake because any of their customers who would have left up try South Beach would have returned back.

    South Beach customer Service Representatives are awful…. in fact I started the program 2 weeks ago and they sent me 3 different versions on how to follow it … so inconsistent and no one there knows what they are talking about . I am locked in for another month with them then I heading back to Nutrisytem’s program.

    Helpful(0) Unhelpful(0)You have already voted this
  4. Getting a subscription cancelled is almost impossible! Called Chat line. Chat line told me I had to call and “no questions will be asked”. Wrong! I refused to answer any questions when transferred twice to a “consultant”. She said cancellation REQUIRED answering questions.A review of the contract does not support this. I gave her my name and address and emphasized I WAS CANCELLING and hung up. I have my conversation recorded and have a copy of the chat questions/answers and will call my credit card company to stop the auto pay. My husband said that the reason men loose weight with South Beach is because they loose their appetite when eating it. Don’t know how they can make great recipes taste so bad. Interestingly, any attempt to email South Beach (i.e. [email protected]) comes back with a ‘failure notice’. If there was a class action, I would join it. If I have any more problems, I am turning everything over to the State of Texas Attorney General Office. They can usually get the attention of companies who attempt to scam consumers.

  5. 1
    Quality
    20
    Value
    20
    Satisfaction
    20

    The month after we had canceled the south beach diet, they tried to take the fees out of our checking account, first there wasn’t enough money allotted for it to come out, second they were called and we were told it wouldn’t be lifted for four days, that was over Memorial Day and we were out of town on vacation, that was the money we were supposed to use for out trip. Needless to say we weren’t doing any sight seeing

    Helpful(0) Unhelpful(0)You have already voted this
  6. BE AWARE when you order southbeach food on line they automatically set you up with automatic monthly subscription for $300 that they will not take back if you don’t catch the fact that you just signed up for it. Autodelivery means you will be billed and a month worth of food will be sent. I think this is a deceptive way to make money as usual. I should have known better. They also have very poor customer service, acted real nice on phone but would not take food back, give me a discount or anything….then left me on hold for 45 minutes only to disconnect me. I got no where trying to talk to them. The diet itself is good-most of the food was ok, the real benefit being it made it much easier to stay on the diet because the real challenge is the time it takes to make all the food if you work.

  7. When I called to cancel my order, the lady asked me a thousand questions. What food do you normally eat, How much food, and so on. When I mentioned the old South Beach entrees and how good they were, she stated “South Beach never had entrees before.” I know they did…. That’s so sad that their a rip off.

  8. 0.5
    Quality
    10
    Value
    10
    Satisfaction
    10

    Food is terrible. I lost some weight on phase one, but none on phase two and it’s hard to stay on when you have to hold your nose just to eat it. I called to stop my next shipment and of course the first person I spoke to had to transfer me to what must have been the “closer”, because she kept asking questions to try and convince me not to cancel. Didn’t work, but now I have to pay over $100 just to cancel my order. Geez. I won’t make that mistake again and will definitly tell all who will listen not to as well!

    Helpful(0) Unhelpful(0)You have already voted this
  9. These meals are disgusting and I cant see to get out of it because I got some sort of deal that I have to pay back a portion. The chicken is chewy and gross… Any advice in how to get out of this plan?

  10. 0.5
    Quality
    10
    Value
    10
    Satisfaction
    10

    My thoughts EXACTLY!!!! this is the worst excuse for food that you could imagine. 99% of it is completely inedible….disgusting. You can lose weight by eating cardboard, and it would taste better, too. I wasted the same $300 as Agnes above, then when I called to cancel, they said I owed them $125 for early cancellation fee since I didn’t get 2 months of “product”. They are extremely arrogant, rude and obnoxious on the phone…that is, when you can finally get to speak to someone. I sent 3 emails and had 2 chats…none of the emails were returned and the chat people said they couldn’t help me. I sat on hold for over 30 minutes to speak to a person who was rude and unhelpful. I alerted my credit card company and disputed the cancellation charge. AVOID THIS SCAM AT ALL COSTS!!!!

    Helpful(0) Unhelpful(0)You have already voted this
  11. The prepackaged South Beach Diet is now owned by Nurtrisystem. South Beach would not admit it when I asked them but one of my e-mails to them bounced (they don’t like to talk to unhappy customers) and the return address was Nutrisystem. So I googled it. They were bought out by Nurtisystem. Nurtisystem inherited a company with a lot of dissatisfied customers. I used Nurtisystem about 10 years ago, never had any problems with them and their food tastes better.

  12. This stuff is DISGUSTING. Sure, you can lose weight on it…you can also lose weight by eating worms. I bought a month’s worth of this at some $300 and I ended up throwing it all out after the 3rd day. The pictures look amazing. The TV commercials are enticing…but the food is mush and barely edible. (NutriSystem, which I did several years ago, is better BY FAR.) I found their customer service, which I called twice, fine…but they wouldn’t let me get out so easily. I had to order another shipment before they’d let me out. Read the fine print!

  13. AWFUL, HORRIBLE Customer service!!!Have now been on the phone for almost 1.5 hours. Transferred to, not exaggerating 8 times. Called because needed a refund for an unauthorized shipment. BE CARFUL if you order, twice they set up an automatic delivery account without our authorization. Reason my husband stopped using was because it was giving him hives (yes he went to the doctor). Unbelievable.

  14. 1
    Quality
    20
    Value
    20
    Satisfaction
    20

    I want to repeat what I just read. I also received a second order I did not expect, nor want. I had no room and had to use a friends freezer. I tried the first couple of weeks and did lose some weight. However, the entrees are terrible. They are small, containing very little protein as chicken or beef. I needed to doctor it up with Teriyaki sauce or ketchup. The only good things are the shakes and the bars which you can buy in any supermarket. The omelets were like hockey pucks. I’ve been giving it away but my friends agree with me. A big waste of time and my money.

    Helpful(0) Unhelpful(0)You have already voted this
  15. I initially did this diet with some neighbors that insisted I join them. I just had a baby about a year prior and was still not back to my pre-pregnancy body. Plus, like my friends keep telling me, “You can do anything for two weeks. It’s just not that long. Will admit the first week was hard, but only because I had been eating more poorly than I realized. After the first two weeks, I just stopped craving the sugar and other crap food. It was so easy by then, I just stayed on the phase one portion for a month. Incredibly, I lost 20 lbs! I have never truly lost weight on a diet before and it’s why I just didn’t believe in it. I can also tell you that it was a complete lifestyle change. I was 33 at the time and to this day, I never put sugar in my coffee and have not had a drink of soda in about 13 years! The weight never rebounded, because I never went back to my old way of eating and it inspired me to be more diligent with my food choices and more respectful of my body and health. Over the years and maybe the best part is that my kids have benefited from this commitment as well and at a time when our kids are generally less healthy, mine are strong, lean and healthy- better yet, they understand how to manage it for themselves. I have come back to this diet over the years as a refresh on my habits and to detox my body. I HIGHLY RECOMMEND THIS PROGRAM! The book was cheap – they are not just after your money. (Note: I have not tried the meal delivery service, I just read the book and prepared the suggested meals. I enjoyed the recipes and it was very easy to implement the program.)

  16. If you goggle search the South Beach diet. There’s the “Induction Phase”, that lasts at least 2 wks. maybe 3. In that phase there are no sweets except artificial sweetener. This phase is to get you past craving sugar and it’s the hardest phase. No sugar, not even fruit. Sugar equals carbs. Phase 2 starts allowing certain fruit and veggies that contain “healthy carbs”. Find their official site. There’s lots of info, “Foods Allowed in Phase 1, 2 and 3. Chat with others on the diet. Recipes for each phase. I see people are NOT happy with this stuff that’s being sold here or how they’re running their “business”. Blow this off, you don’t need to pay anything at the official South Beach Diet site.

  17. It is just tiny portions. I was amazed when I read the calories for such a miniscule amount of food on their packages. I now have a great high protein breakfast, 3 scrambled eggs with a smattering of feta cheese = 210 calories. Better than any breakfast of microwaved food.

  18. Reply
    ROBERT STEVEN REESER July 17, 2019 at 11:49 am

    $425 wasted. Food looks nothing like the box photos. Turns to mush when its cooked. Flavors all blend. Called today to cancel was charged $125 to do so. Online chat customer service said I could get a refund then said ignore what I said and I would have to pay full price, she had made a mistake with providing false info. I have been on Nutri-system and loved it but thought id give South Beach a chance. BIG MISTAKE.. a company that doesnt back thier product YOU SHOULD NEVER BUY FROM………… Going to throw out the remaining food. Only 3 days in and cant stomach it. South Beach you should be ashamed of your products and lack of customer service.. OH and the APP never works and trying to get someone online took 8 attempts and over 1 hour………. VERY DISAPPOINTED…

  19. My wife and I ordered the South Beach 4 week delivery plan for around $675. By far the worst food we have eaten and they should be charged with false advertising after seeing what is on the box vs. reality (SB will blame the microwave settings which isn’t the case).
    My opinion is to stay well away from South Beach delivery option. We even threw away much of what was delivered as we couldn’t even give it away.

  20. I also am very mad about that. I canceled because the food is gross! They charged my bank account $125.00 for cancellation fees. I called and ripped them a new one. I’m so pissed.

  21. 1.15
    Quality
    20
    Value
    20
    Satisfaction
    30

    Started the diet with high expectations, the food was not good at all. decided to try another way. Anyway, I got on the website and tried to cancel, this is another business that makes it very difficult to stop their program. There was no way to cancel online, so I got on chat and they could not help, he gave me a number to call. I called the number and a lady would not accept my decision to just quit, she had a million questions about why and how I could do the program another way, I pleaded that “I JUST WANT TO STOP THE PROGRAM” Anyway, it ended with me having to pay another 135.00 dollars and another shipment of crap food, because of the “discount” on my first shipment that I had to go at least two months into the program. I will never deal with online diets again!! So disappointed with Southbeach.

    Helpful(0) Unhelpful(0)You have already voted this
  22. Biggest waste of money ever. The food was truly disgusting. They do not guarantee their product – you don’t like it that’s your problem and you’re out the $300. And their “week free” with sign up includes signing you up for their auto delivery. Even more expensive nasty food forced on you. If you try to cancel they charge $125 for that “free week”.

    The food is filled with preservatives and other fake food ingredients. The carb count was crazy high – in Phase I! Starch in snacks! The South Beach diet works, but this isn’t that diet. I actually GAINED WEIGHT with this garbage.

    Summary:

    GROSS FAKE FOOD. No refunds, no guarantees.

    Automatically signed up for FORCED AUTO DELIVERY which costs $125 to cancel.

    GAINED WEIGHT.

    Stay far far away.

  23. I agree about the deceptive business practice and not making the cancellation of $99 known until after the order is cancelled. The food was not good and caused my diabetes to get way out of control after just one week. Had to stop the diet to get back control. If you are diabetic or pre-diabetic do not go on this diet!

  24. I have been attempting to use the SBD food for 2 weeks and I have had it. This is the worst food I have ever attempted to eat. The Phase 1 foods are so bad that I couldn’t eat any of it. It smelled bad after it was heated and it tasted worse. I have lost 5 pounds because I am starving. Paid 300 for the food, what a waste of good food. It does, however, make me appreciate the taste of fresh food, like tomatoes, broccoli, brussells sprouts, anything but the food they send you. Please don’t waste your money. 300 dollars down the drain. Oh, I tried the Phase 2 foods just to see if I could stand it, I could not.

  25. 10 yrs. ago I lost 65 pnds. on South Beach in 1 yr. I now need to loose about 35 pnds that have jumped back on within the past 2 yrs. In that 2 yr. period I moved to Tx. from Ca. and started eating very differently. From Cal. fresh veggies and fruit of all kinds to Tx. biscuits and gravy and a heavy dose of carbs at every meal. Plus, just as much a factor if not more so I now use a wheel chair nearly always. Ten years ago when I went on South Beach I talked to my Neurologist about it. He said having the extra weight isn’t good for me so get the weight off then go back to eating a healthy balanced diet. South Beach is very difficult to stick to especially in the beginning. Carbs are equal to sugar and cutting ALL sugar can cause withdrawal symptoms. I’ll need to clean out my pantry so there are no temptations. I equate it to stopping smoking, well maybe not that tough but it’s hard and will consume my every thought for the 1st 2 wks. I’ll stay in the induction phase longer than 2 wks. as South Beach says, or used to say that’s safe. What makes the diet a little easier to stay on is I’ll see the weight drop rapidly and that motivates me in a big way. It seems I remember it was more like 5 pnds off per wk. for the 1st 2-3 wks at least for me. Good luck with whatever you decide.

    Leave a review

    Your total score

     ConsumersCompare.org